Ads are not an endorsement by the blog author.

Stay Hot and in Love

Public Journal
 Back to Journal Archives | Subscribe to Alerts Alerts Subscribe to Alerts | Feeds
< Who Is Most Passi
Thursday, May 3, 2007
Your First Kiss >
Wednesday, May 9, 2007
May 2007
Thursday, May 3, 2007

To Keep or Not to Keep

"When you break up with someone are you supposed to give back the jewelry they gave you?"

Have you kept presents that were given to you after a relationship ended? What have you done in this situation?



commonsensediva at 10:34:00 AM EDT Blog about this entry
This entry has 5 comments: (Add your own)
  • #5 Comment from sexyvane20070 
    6/3/07 11:46 PM Permalink
    IT depend if you left the person for someone else  you suppose to give back the things they gave you because not only you left them but you break their heart but if he cheated on you its yours to keep because if you think of all the B.S you deal with you deserve it  and more than that . if they just leave you because they looking for something new is still yours  to keep  so you better enjoy it.
  • #4 Comment from auldfiere 
    6/2/07 11:31 AM Permalink
    Any gift I've ever given to anyone, regardless of the relationship, wasn't something that I would have wanted back simply because of a negative change in the relationship.  I'm not an Indian-giver, and, especially with respect to the women I have loved, I've never attached strings to anything I've given.

    Someone posted:  "Its not love that holds a marriage together, its commitment. Its your character, not theirs."  The marriage that, in the long run, is held together by commitment and not love, by force of your character and not theirs, is a sad and pathetic marriage.  I'm not sure which is worse, a marriage that is driven primarily by commitment rather than love, or divorce when love isn't the driving force in the marriage.
  • #3 Comment from wendylebeau 
    5/5/07 6:26 PM Permalink
    of course  I kept a  present that was given to me anyways they didn't want it back
    Seeing they bought it for me
  • #2 Comment from robroy143 
    5/5/07 5:00 PM Permalink
    When a man gives his wife gifts, its for his wife, like cou on a cou stick. He's building a trophy or a shrine of his affections. They (gifts)  are to build interest like an investment in this relationship, each piece glorifying the next piece (earrings , necklaces, bracelets etc.) To answer the question, do you keep them, it depends on who is dumping who. If He dumps you, iff (thats if and only if) you have been faithfull, then He is throwing away you with the whole lot. Thats his loss, you were faithfull, you earned them. HOWEVER, if you dump him, those tokens of his affection are for HIS wife, not you, who is calling it quits. Whoever accepts the job,  they are for her to adorn, his wife, this same said position, whom ever that may be. The unfaithfull one to the relationship should leave butt naked, as it were before it all started. If your gonna jump ship on someone, and take the goodies, your stealing. If this were law, I'll bet that almost half of divorce would vanish simply because of how shallow so many people actually are, that they'ed leave their spouce quicker than they leave their rocks. Its not love that holds a marriage together, its commitment. Its your character, not theirs.
  • #1 Comment from ab45yui 
    5/3/07 7:58 PM Permalink
    I guess it depends on the relationship.  If you were married, then I think it would be okay to keep the gifts.  My rule of thumb is any gifts of jewlry I received during my first marriage go to our daughters.