Ads are not an endorsement by the blog author.

Hestia Homeschool for Young Wild Women

Public Journal
 Back to Journal Archives | Subscribe to Alerts Alerts Subscribe to Alerts | Feeds
< One Tin Soldier
Sunday, October 22, 2006
Native American p >
Monday, October 23, 2006
October 2006
Monday, October 23, 2006
2:23:00 AM EDT
Feeling Anxious

waterboarding: torture


My homeschooling family has been following the recent attempts of the Bush Administration's decision to try to sneak around the Geneva Convention with horror. Today we watched this video online:
 
 
Click here: YouTube - is Waterboarding torture? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Fk1uE1SPOo
 
about a torture technique called waterboarding. The professional interrogator (dressed in black) scared the shit out of me just watching him calmly talk about coercive interrogations.
 
I cried. I cannot sleep.
 
Even if the technique does no real physical damage (as they say, it stops well short of causing kidney damage) there is not doubt that a person who endures this involuntarily will probably have psychological problems for the rest of their life.  How do I know this?  Twenty-nine years after surviving a very brutal rape where two young men toyed with me like a cat with a mouse, I am still able to recall in a heartbeat the way they smelled, the taste of a knife in my mouth, the way at one point I decided I wanted to die rather than live one more instant enduring this terror. Terror is worse than pain, believe me. (I gave birth naturally without drugs each time, without crying out or even moaning.  I am not weak about physical pain.)
 
If  Americans want to be able to claim the moral high ground, we must not treat other human beings like this. Period.  And if some of  us hope to claim to be Christian, there is no doubt that Christ would not condone treating another living soul like this, ever, under any circumstances. We are to love our enemies, love those who wronged us.
 


Written by hestiahomeschool Blog about this entry
This entry has 8 comments: (Add your own)
  • #8 Comment from hestiahomeschoolEntry Author 
    10/24/06 1:42 AM Permalink
    I know you weren't saying torture is a good thing. I am thinking of a good response to your question. I've been mulling over it all day.
    love you,
    Kas
  • #7 Comment from sugar1337 
    10/24/06 1:37 AM Permalink
    I wasn't agreeing with physical torture or even mental torture, but some psychological techniques might work?  I think that they need to get information out of people, but I don't think that have enough experince to truly have a humane way of doing it yet but I hope that changes.
    http://blog.myspace.com/poptartcoco
  • #6 Comment from deshelestraci 
    10/23/06 11:34 AM Permalink
    Very true.
    Traci
  • #5 Comment from hestiahomeschoolEntry Author 
    10/23/06 10:37 AM Permalink
    Sugar, there has been a lot of evidence that  has consistantly shown that information obtained as a result of torture is not reliable or necessarily accurate. Under torture, individuals will agree to almost anything, lie, involve innocent people they love, do almost anything to escape.

    If it doesn't work, and the information received is unreliable, and it is ethically wrong, why torture?
  • #4 Comment from queeniemart 
    10/23/06 9:04 AM Permalink
    this was some truly scary stuff to watch!!!!! My biggest fear is drowning  because i can not swim. Thanks for pointing me to the video, THank God that guy was in a controlled situation.
    Love,lj
Show all comments (3 more)