Ads are not an endorsement by the blog author.

AOL Journals: Magic Smoke

Public Journal
 Back to Journal Archives | Subscribe to Alerts Alerts Subscribe to Alerts | Feeds
< Adding Photos to
Wednesday, June 21, 2006
About That Moblog >
Thursday, June 22, 2006
June 2006
Journals Editor Joe's Fourth of July Blog Picks for 6/30
The Great Donut Debate? (and Embedded Polls)
6/29 Journals Status Update 2
Try the Moblogging (Mobile Blogging) Beta
6/29 Journals Status (R7 Beta Rolled Back)
Don't Miss These Entries
Journals R7 Release in Beta
Open Issue: Journals Database Errors
Are You 'Missing' Entries in Your Journal?
For the Fourth: Fireworks Photos and Your July 4th Blogs
That Strange Thing in the Sky That Hurts My Eyes
Drama, Manufactured and Historical
About That Moblogging Beta...
eBay Sniping and You
CLEARED: Journals Issues Due to Rostering Problems
6/27: Journals Issues Due to Rostering Problem
6/27 Journals Status: A Bad News, Good News Sort of Thing
Moist Monday
New Guest Editor's Picks for 6/23
Stormy Weather Ahead (Plus, Sidebar Material)
About That Moblogging Entry I Promised...
Jakob Nielsen on Blogs vs. Newsletters
Adding Photos to Your Journal With AOL Pictures Permalinks
This Is Not an Update
Blogging for Fun and Profit (or, "Man [Behind] for the Dixie Chicks")
Blogging for Business & Pleasure
New Guest Editor's Picks for 6/16 (Plus, a Sneak Peek at Next Week)
'Pearls' on Bloggers and Comments
Joe Explains Social Link Sharing Sites (Except Not Boring This Time)
About the Latest Weekend Assignment
Social Link Sharing and The New Netscape Beta
I'm Sorry, Britney...
Flag Day & Some Photo Tips
Fixed: Editing Journals Entries
Workaround for Editing/Deleting Existing Entries
Problems Editing Journals Entries (Plus, a Fix)
Status of R6 Fixes (AOL Pictures and Double Quotes)
Problem With Duplicate Description Text Showing Up in Header
Journals R6 Release Successfully Installed
Journals R6 Release Is "Go" for Launch, 6/13, 4am ET
New Guest Editor's Picks for 6/9
Blog Six-Pack Picks, 2.10
Watch What You Say (Redux)
Blog Six-Pack Picks, 2.9
Journals Release R6 Is Coming
Power to the People (and Serenity Now!)
Blog Six-Pack Picks, 2.8
You Know What Today Is, Right?
Blog Six-Pack Picks, 2.7
Journals Editor Joe's Blog Picks for 6/2
Live Video Stream of Space Station Spacewalk
Leveling Up in HTML Knowledge
Hello, June (and a Little Printable Propaganda)
« June 2006 Archive
Thursday, June 22, 2006
8:19:00 PM EDT

Jakob Nielsen on Blogs vs. Newsletters

Hi folks -- here's a bit of contrarian opinion about companies, blogs and RSS feeds in this week's Wall Street Journal (link via Slashdot, which as always, has an interesting discussion thread) from usability guru Jakob Nielsen.

Mr. Nielsen is an influential, but also very polarizing, personality when it comes to Web page design. For example, if you look at his Web site, you'll see that it's pretty much all text, with minimal formatting.

(I'm a big fan of text, and I do agree that a lot of designers get carried away out of touch from users. However, I'm not a purist like Mr. Nielsen. In fact, I think his site's main page is amazingly annoying, for all its simplicity and speed.)

Anyway, here are a few tidbits from his Wall Street Journal interview, where he gives his opinions on how companies use technology like RSS to talk to users and customers:
  • Most people still don't know what "RSS" is. "News feeds" is a better term (a feed lets you subscribe to something; your blog entries, your eBay auctions, your sports scores -- all of these things can have feeds, which you can subscribe to and read in a feed reader. It's a good way to organize information from a bunch of different sources.)

  • There's a place for traditional newsletters; blogs aren't perfect for everything.

  • Blogs are conversations... but only for your most fanatic readers. For more periodic communications, a newsletter on a regular publishing schedule might be better.
Personally, I think Mr. Nielsen is taking a very limited view how companies can use blogs, seeing them strictly as a one-way distribution mechanism ("one-to-many", to use the jargon).

However, that loses the importance of what makes blogs "conversations" -- interactivity; listening to users's feedback, responding to their suggestions, and participating in the broader discussion going on in the world (through comments, links to other blogs, etc.).

If you just want to have a newsletter; well, just have a newsletter. Buteven then, there are still advantages to the blog format -- searchable archives, primarily.

Also, with things like New Entry alerts, the line between a blog entry and a newsletter gets kind of blurred, anyway. And the ability to subscribe to a blog's feed means that if you're already using a feed reader, you can just add that to your routine, instead of going off to e-mail.

Just some food for thought.

Thanks -- Joe
Tags: , ,

Written by journalseditor Blog about this entry
This entry has 0 comments: (Add your own)