Ads are not an endorsement by the blog author.

AOL Journals: Magic Smoke

Public Journal
 Back to Journal Archives | Subscribe to Alerts Alerts Subscribe to Alerts | Feeds
< The Downside of "
Friday, September 8, 2006
Remembering 9/11 >
Friday, September 8, 2006
September 2006
Guest Editor 9/29/06
Please Help Us Fix R8
Enough Shovels of Dirt
Temporary Rollback to R7
Bug Fixes, Open Issues 9/27/06
Hiccups in the SNS, Edit Entry Process?
Journals R8 Install 9/26/06, Outage From 4-6 AM EST
Virgin Festival Photos, Roundup
Guest Editor 9/22/06
Journals Outages Now Fixed
Spell-Check is Fixed
Dragonfly, Hippopotami, Blogger Tools
Journals Down, Back Up
New Guy, New Links, Same Scene
One-Legged Man in a Production of 'Riverdance'
Well, I Guess That's All Folks ...
How To: Make and Edit Hyperlinks
Editing in Text Mode vs. HTML Mode
Some Changes Are Afoot
How Are Blogs Like A-Rod? (Plus, Submitting Links to Social Link Sites)
Blogging: The Only Winning Move Is Not to Play?
Health Good News/Bad News (Plus, Using Blockquotes)
9/11 Remembrances on the Web
Remembering 9/11
Only the Lonely?
The Downside of "Let the Fans Decide"
The Ultimate Blog Post?
Doogie Howser, F.B. (First Blogger)?
Journals Alerts Problems Should Be Fixed
The Evening News Just Got Perkier
Update on Alerts Status, Plus Scheduled Maintenance, 9/7, 4AM ET
Following Up on Unfinished Business
Problems With Journals New Entry/Comment Added Alerts?
Hello, September (redux)
Everywhere There's Signs
Hello, September (Sort of) and Cherry-Picking the Boards
« September 2006 Archive
Friday, September 8, 2006
7:13:00 PM EDT
Hearing Echobelly, Angel

Only the Lonely?

Okay folks, I've been avoiding this story until now, but it just got more interesting this week.

Over the course of the past few months, a new "It Girl" appeared on social video-sharing site YouTube. She was a homeschooled 15-year-old girl, posting video blog entries for the first time using her webcam -- she went by the name Bree and had the username lonelygirl15:

YouTube's Lonelygirl15
Lonelygirl15's first video posting.

She's perky and cute (for some reason, the terms "big-eyed" and "doe-eyed" keep getting used to describe her), and because of this, she started getting an insane amount of attention and a legion of fans.

Now, as is typical with this kind of Internet celebrity, people kept wanting to find out more about her, especially as word spread to the press (like the Times of London).

There were, however, doubters. Besides being too cute, people started twigging to little details: The video looked a little too good; she didn't talk about anything current; what was with the mysterious references to religious rituals (not to mention a framed photo of occultist Aleister Crowley); oh, and did we mention that someone registered her domain a month before the first video blog post?

A trio of folks from one of her Internet message boards (yes, she had fansites and message boards devoted to her) set up a sting, involving checking IP addresses and her MySpace profile. They found out that e-mails from "lonelygirl15" were originating from Beverly Hills-based Creative Artists Agency.

"Bree"'s creators came clean on one of the fan message boards (which is now down -- you can find the text of their post on blog sociologist It Girl Danah Boyd's blog). They claim they're all filmmakers and that "Bree" was conceived as some sort of high-minded art project ("Lonelygirl15 is a reflection of everyone. She is no more real or fictitious than the portions of our personalities that we choose to show (or hide) when we interact with the people around us..." blah blah blah), though especially given the CAA connection and the occult references in the video, it's hard to figure this isn't indeed a viral promotion for an upcoming horror movie or as part of an Alternate Reality Game (as many have speculated).

Reactions around the Internet range from "I knew it!" to "You fake !@#$%"; sample some commentary from Metafilter (including this one that suggests they really blew the reveal); the Fark thread and even the Wikipedia entry.

I suppose now is the right time to do my own reveal: The editor you know as "Joe" is actually an amalgam of seven different people in three different countries; together, we assemble and publish the incessant blather and occasional useful tidbit for this blog....

Okay, I would finish that bit, but I know that people don't read, sarcasm doesn't come through well in text, and someone might actually take that paragraph seriously. So I just wanted you to know that, yes, I am real.

It's "blogger John Scalzi" who's the complete fabrication.

Thanks -- Joe


Written by journalseditor Blog about this entry
This entry has 10 comments: (Add your own)
  • #10 Comment from monponsett 
    9/10/06 9:41 AM Permalink
    Sh*t... there go my plans to lure her into meeting me at a Connecticut hotel. It's getting so that one just can't trust the teen children one plans to abduct anymore.
  • #9 Comment from inafrnz247 
    9/10/06 12:05 AM Permalink
    Okay... that is just too strange.
  • #8 Comment from trksoccer 
    9/9/06 3:11 PM Permalink
    lonelygirl15 was on the 11 o'clock news last night.

    you can watch it here...

    http://www.wusatv9.com/news/news_article.aspx?storyid=51970

  • #7 Comment from rebuketheworld 
    9/9/06 2:07 AM Permalink
    I was wondering what that was all about. People getting so upset about that is silly. She does look innocent. I could never get away with that. My acting coach in college told me,,,"sweetie, you could never sell milk." lol..Its true. She got away with it because of the look but I think its funny.
  • #6 Comment from wipforever 
    9/8/06 7:59 PM Permalink
    Funny - I uncovered some dirt on another blogger on AOL who was pretending to be a bunch of different people and I got called a "stalker".  

    Sheila
Show all comments (5 more)