Ads are not an endorsement by the blog author.

Sober Gay Poz Ex-Con

Public Journal
 Back to Journal Archives | Subscribe to Alerts Alerts Subscribe to Alerts | Feeds
< New Under The Sun
Monday, July 21, 2008
Calm and Storms >
Wednesday, July 23, 2008
July 2008
Tuesday, July 22, 2008
12:12:00 PM EDT

Fear and Change


FidlerReni.jpgFirst and foremost, it is impossible for me not to be hyperaware that today, after a decade, Steven gets out of prison. This is like the opening ceremonies of the Olympics. For him, walking in them, for me, watching them. He's probably just now getting on a bus to a halfway house in Sioux Falls, South Dakota. Wow.

Like many of us, I am entranced by Obama's trip abroad, thrilled by how well it's going. I loved the cheers of the troops as he sunk that three-pointer--I'm sure Dick Cheney had to adjust his pacemaker to "apoplectic" that Bush-friendly troops were not pre-chosen to guarantee a stony instead of an obviously warm reception to the other "O." (Who'd have thought she'd have competition?) I loved loved loved when McCain, the supposed one with foreign policy expertise, talked about the non-existent "Iraq/Pakistan" border (they are 750 miles apart, separated by Iran), especially as I imagined Dumbya being told by Condi that McCain had made a mistake, because he still can't find Afghanistan on a map.

I am of course dismayed by the continued tenacity of the "radical muslim" perception that seems firmly entrenched in the minds of the the under and miseducated. I have a theory about that, particularly when it comes to the elderly.

One of the reasons it was so nice to be an American in the 40s and 50s was that it wasn't an illusion that we were "the good guys."  The Fascist ideologies we fought really were evil, and we really were liberators who could be trusted not to torture. By the 60s, things got a bit more ambiguous, but it was still relatively easy to feel like whatever our flaws, the Russians were worse--as any Hungarian, Czech or Ukrainian who got out from under the Soviet boot could tell you.  If you'd made it into your 60s or 70s, you were used to 4 decades of good guyism, but probably just a tad disoriented by century's end that there was no clear, monolithic enemy to reinforce your sense of contrast.

Then comes 9/11.   A tragedy to be sure, but there's the comfortable feeling of certainty you had after Pearl Harbor that you are the wounded and righteous party. But these bad guys, who are they? Senators couldn't tell the difference between Sunni and Shia--or is it Shiite? Oh, it was Saddam Hussein? Well, there you go. Oh but it wasn't?  Finally, you throw up you hands, settling on the idea that our enemy are Radical Muslim Extremists.  True, Bush is not Einstein, but at least when you look at him, he seems to be without any doubt as to the basic certainty that we are the good guys. You need to believe that about your country, about yourself. Children can turn against you, spouses can die, businesses can go belly up, life can be cruel and uncertain. But if America isn't the good guy, what does that make you?

Barack Obama represents a nuanced view of the world that makes you uncomfortable. He asks America to take responsiblity for its foreign policy mistakes, to understand that if so many hate us it may be related to how we operate in the world.  If you agree with that, then you may have to question whether you have something to do with why your daugher never visits, why your husband or wife divorced you, why you have to live on $1800 a month even though you worked non-stop since the depression.  (The equivalent scenario can be painted with working class whites whose patriotism also gets all tied up with compensating for poor self-esteem.)

Casting Obama as a muslim extremist, as ridiculous as that is, represents a need for a clear and defined bad guy, like the good old days of the Nazis and the Russians. Killing Saddam didn't fix terrorism, and who can keep all these Arabs straight? McCain is 72, an ex- POW, unambigous.  Obama is mixed race, his middle name is Hussein, he even looks like an Arab. Most of all, he's unfamiliar in a time where familiarity is craved.

They fear Obama, because he represents a new world where being American is not an automatic grant of moral superiority, in which the survival of the world may actually depend on some hard long stocktaking in the mirror. To them, Obama's a Pandora's Box of guilt and self-questioning that must not be opened. Better to slap a simplistic label on him and play some mah-jong.

MCO 2008 

P.S. The Hy-Art is Reni/Fidler. Can't say it's much related to the blog entry, but it's what created itself last night.


Tags: ,


Written by makemarc Blog about this entry
This entry has 4 comments: (Add your own)
  • #4 Comment from ceilisundancer 
    7/25/08 3:40 PM Permalink
    I need to re-read all of your Obama stuff here to absorb it properly (and you know I'm a fan of his), but hasten to say YEAH to Steven.  He's now served his time and is moving forward in his life.  May God be with him, and things go well.
  • #3 Comment from aimer 
    7/22/08 5:54 PM Permalink
    Your theory is Huffington Post worthy stuff; it needs to be shared with a broad audience. This is a spot on analysis of the source of the fear and the clinging to the myth of Obama the Muslim extremist. Clear, cogent thoughts and skillful writing--a powerful combination.--Sheria

  • #2 Comment from gazker 
    7/22/08 5:28 PM Permalink
    Many Brits look on in awe and watch as Obama makes his trip abroad. It's time America looked to the future and showed the world that you can truly lead our planet to a peacefull co-existence. We in the UK are not the great and powerfull we once were. We realise what the British Empire did, history tell us. Hopefully in the future Americans will look back on their past mistakes (those being done now).
    If America is to lead the world, we dont need wrinkled old right wing skeletons. We need some one with foresight.
    America needs to take the bull by the horns and vote in Obama, it won't happen because of his skin colour.
    Sadly, I feel you as a country couldn't cope with this yet. Please prove me wrong.
    Gaz
  • #1 Comment from justplainbill 
    7/22/08 2:15 PM Permalink
    Marc, glaad to hear that Steven has survived his imprisonment. Tried for another word rather than survivied but had it beenm me I think that is the way I would look at it.
    At 77 and having seen so manyu changes over the years, I belive we will all survive no matter what happens in the USA and things for most of us will continue to be good. I have not lost all hope. My grandchildren weill make it. Bill